europe
Macron leaves Francophonie summit with leadership dispute deferred
French President Emmanuel Macron left the Francophonie summit in Cambodia on Monday with uncertainty still surrounding the leadership of the French-speaking organisation after a dispute between Rwanda and Congo disrupted the proceedings.
Following intense negotiations over the weekend and into Monday, member states agreed that incumbent Secretary-General Louise Mushikiwabo of Rwanda would remain in office for another year before a new leader is selected.
Mushikiwabo was seeking a third term at the summit, but Congo strongly opposed her reappointment and even threatened to withdraw from the Organisation internationale de la Francophonie (OIF) if she was reelected.
With a population of more than 110 million, significantly larger than France's 70 million, Congo's withdrawal would deal a major blow to the organisation.
Congo, the United States and UN experts have accused Rwanda of supporting the M23, one of around 100 armed groups seeking control in mineral-rich eastern Congo along the Rwandan border. Rwanda has consistently denied providing support to armed groups operating in Congo.
The French president's office welcomed the decision to postpone the leadership change for a year, saying it would help the organisation "to overcome divisions and preserve the consensus in the francophone family."
Congo's Foreign Minister Thérèse Kayikwamba Wagner also welcomed the arrangement, describing it in a post on X as "a wise compromise" that would help maintain unity within the Francophonie.
The OIF concluded its three-day meetings on Monday. Macron held bilateral discussions with several leaders, including Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet and Vietnamese leader To Lam, and attended the summit of the organisation, which comprises 90 member states and governments, including 53 full members, five associate members and 32 observers.
On Sunday, the French president's office said Macron had met Rwandan President Paul Kagame and urged the three African countries putting forward candidates for the OIF leadership — Rwanda, Congo and Mauritania — to hold discussions and reach a "consensus solution."
France holds considerable influence in the organisation as its largest contributor to the 2026 OIF budget of 71.7 million euros ($79 million).
The leadership controversy follows the withdrawal of Mali, Niger and Burkina Faso from the OIF, announced in March 2025 after their memberships were suspended over military coups.
Meanwhile, rights organisations and UN Special Rapporteur Tom Andrews urged world leaders attending the summit to press Cambodia to release rights activists and ensure greater democratic freedoms in the country, which operates as a de facto one-party state.
Cambodia-Thailand tensions feature during Macron's visit
Cambodia's dispute with Thailand also drew attention during Macron's visit.
Prime Minister Hun Manet, who chaired the summit, criticised Thailand in his opening address on Sunday and reiterated that Cambodia had not initiated the fighting between the two Southeast Asian neighbours in 2025 over competing claims to border territories.
The clashes killed several dozen civilians and soldiers on both sides and displaced hundreds of thousands of people.
Macron praised Hun Manet for choosing peace as the summit's theme and said France supported renewed dialogue to achieve a peaceful, negotiated settlement of border disputes.
In a Facebook post on Sunday, Thai Prime Minister Anutin Charnvirakul said Thailand had "always respected all agreements with Cambodia and will always adhere to international law."
He also reiterated Bangkok's position that bilateral disputes should be settled without third-party involvement.
Thailand's reluctance to involve outside parties is partly linked to two rulings by the International Court of Justice granting Cambodia ownership of a centuries-old temple on disputed land along the border.
Macron inaugurates restored temple before leaving for Malaysia
Before departing for Malaysia, Macron visited Siem Reap on Monday, where he joined Cambodian King Norodom Sihamoni in marking the completion of a French-supported restoration project at the West Mebon temple near the Angkor Wat complex, a UNESCO World Heritage site.
Cambodia's Apsara National Authority told The Associated Press that the restoration of the 11th-century temple, built during the Angkor era, cost $12 million and took 14 years to complete.
The joint French-Cambodian project involved transporting replacement stones and heavy machinery by boat to the island temple while managing water levels to prevent flooding during seasonal rains.
The temple had suffered damage from natural elements, human activities and war.
Macron arrived in Malaysia later on Monday and was scheduled to meet Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim for talks expected to focus on defence cooperation and the supply of critical minerals.
His Southeast Asian tour comes amid widespread protests in France, where more than 600,000 people took to the streets earlier this month demanding higher wages and expressing support for the country's student protest movement.
The demonstrations have resulted in thousands of arrests, hundreds of injuries and several schools being set on fire.
1 day ago
5 European countries aim to send rejected migrants to center in Rwanda
A group of European countries announced on Monday that it aims to set up a "migrant hub" in Rwanda where rejected asylum-seekers could be sent from next year.
The European Union has worked for years to tighten migration rules, push down the number of asylum-seekers coming to the 27-nation bloc and increase deportations of migrants who aren't entitled to stay. Sending people to centers outside Europe has emerged as a central plank of that effort.
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands have spearheaded negotiations.
Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker, speaking alongside officials from the other European countries and Rwanda's interior minister, said the aim is for the first center to be set up in Rwanda next year.
"I think this will be a game changer making us able to confront the massive challenges with illegal migration," Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said of the accord the Europeans hope to finalize. "We will break down the business model of human smugglers. We will take back control of our borders and we will remove the incentives for illegal migration."
Human rights groups have criticized plans to deport migrants to centers or prisons in third countries, arguing that European nations cannot guarantee their rights will be respected there.
"Offshore deportation centers are the latest cynical expression of the EU's drive to shift its responsibilities to other countries," Clementine de Montjoye, senior Africa researcher and Rwanda expert at Human Rights Watch, said in a statement. "Paying Kigali to host a deportation program would not only cause suffering and harm to those deported, it would finance and provide political leverage to a government responsible for serious human rights abuses at home and abroad."
But advocates have argued that the so-called "return hubs" will offer an opportunity for migrants who can't return to their own countries but have no legal basis to come to Europe. European officials have insisted that the new hubs would abide by European and international law.
EU laws have changed in recent years due to persistent public and political pressure for tougher measures against migration.
European lawmakers voted in June to allow member states to set up centers outside the EU on their own or in small coalitions, and send rejected asylum seekers there instead of to their home countries.
1 day ago
Hundreds of thousands protest Czech government's plan to change public media funding
Hundreds of thousands of people gathered in Prague on Sunday to protest the Czech government's plan to overhaul the funding system for public broadcasters, warning that the move could undermine media independence and democracy.
The massive rally took place at Letná Park, a historic site where large crowds assembled during the 1989 Velvet Revolution that ended more than four decades of communist rule in the country.
The demonstration, held two days before the anniversary of the 1989 protests, drew an estimated 350,000 people, according to Mikuláš Minář, the lead organiser of the Million Moments for Democracy group.
The protesters demanded that the government abandon the plan and voiced concerns over the policies of billionaire Prime Minister Andrej Babiš and his coalition partners.
"We do witness here something extraordinary today," Minář said, adding, "It's just a beginning."
Under the proposed changes, public radio and television broadcasters would receive funding from the state budget instead of the existing system of regular fees paid by individuals, households and businesses.
The broadcasters would receive around 15 percent less funding than they currently do, potentially leading to job cuts, reduced production and programme cancellations.
Critics argue that the proposed changes would allow the three-party coalition government to exert control over public media, drawing comparisons with developments under populist governments in Slovakia led by Prime Minister Robert Fico and in Hungary before former Prime Minister Viktor Orbán was removed from power in April.
"We refuse the Slovak scenario," read one protest banner, while another declared, "Hands off the media."
Singer Šarka Dumišincová, who joined the demonstration, said the media represented freedom and that attempts to control that freedom were unacceptable.
Government accused of rushing legislation through parliament
The ruling coalition unexpectedly advanced the proposed changes in the lower house of parliament on October 24.
Before voting at 4:36am to pass the bill through its first of three parliamentary readings, government lawmakers restricted the time available for opposition members to speak.
Thousands of people took to the streets the following day to protest the process, while employees of public media organisations staged a strike on November 3.
The strike received support from labour unions, universities, students, churches, artists, athletes and international media organisations, among others.
"We are here to stand up against the rule by force in the style of 4:36," Minář said at Sunday's rally, referring to the time the bill passed its first reading.
Media freedom and the rule of law in the Czech Republic were also discussed at the European Parliament on Wednesday.
EU Justice Commissioner Michael McGrath said national legislation must ensure that public service media funding is based on transparent and objective criteria and provides "adequate, sustainable and predictable financial resources."
Babiš rejects criticism, vows to proceed with plan
Despite the protests, Babiš has pledged to move forward with the proposed changes, denying that they would affect media freedom.
He returned to power after his ANO, or YES, movement won last year's election and formed a coalition with two smaller political groups — the anti-immigration and pro-Russian Freedom and Direct Democracy party, and the right-wing Motorists for Themselves.
Babiš has opposed several key European Union policies on the environment and migration, rejected financial assistance for Ukraine and opposed guarantees for EU loans intended to help the country defend itself against Russia's invasion.
His government has also faced criticism from NATO allies over its failure to spend enough on defence.
Sunday's protesters also criticised the government's defence policy and called for the resignation of Freedom and Direct Democracy leader and parliamentary Speaker Tomio Okamura, as well as Defence Minister Jaromír Zůna. The party controls the defence ministry.
"While (Russia's President Vladimir) Putin threatens Europe, the pro-Russian (party) is systematically undermining the state's defensive capability and endangering national security," Minář said.
2 days ago
Nearly 2,200 migrants reach Canary Islands in 2 days, Spain says
Nearly 2,200 migrants have reached Spain’s Canary Islands by boat over the past two days, Spain’s maritime rescue service said on Sunday.
The archipelago off northwest Africa is a major entry point for migrants, mainly from West Africa, attempting the dangerous Atlantic crossing in makeshift boats. More than 13,000 of the just over 28,000 people who arrived in Spain by sea between January and the end of October landed in the Canary Islands, according to the Interior Ministry.
Spain declared a migration emergency on the islands on Tuesday following a rise in arrivals in recent weeks, particularly from sub-Saharan Africa. The country is due to hold an early general election in two weeks.
The rescue service said it had assisted 1,324 people aboard 14 dinghies, most of whom reached El Hierro, an island with a population of 12,000. That figure approached the route’s daily rescue record of 1,461 people, set on Nov. 7, 2020.
Red Cross staff meet migrants at the port, providing dry clothes, food and water and registering their arrival, Dácil León, the organization’s emergency coordinator in Tenerife, told public broadcaster RTVE.
The Atlantic crossing between West Africa and the Canary Islands is one of the world’s deadliest migration routes. Although the islands lie about 65 miles (105 kilometers) from the nearest African coast, many migrants take longer routes to evade security forces. Those journeys can last days or weeks, with most boats departing from Mauritania.
In July, tens of thousands of people crossed from Morocco into Spain’s North African territory of Ceuta in just two days, causing chaos and reigniting debate over immigration in Europe and beyond. More than 140 people died making the journey.
Most of those who crossed left within days, but up to 15,000 remained.
2 days ago
Tens of thousands protest rising house prices in Portugal
Tens of thousands of people marched through more than 30 cities and towns across Portugal on Saturday in the largest protest yet against soaring housing costs that many say have put buying or renting a home beyond their reach.
The housing crisis has fueled weeks of demonstrations. Some activists have camped in central squares in Lisbon and Porto, the country’s two largest cities. Riot police with dogs have dispersed some protests, drawing accusations of heavy-handed tactics.
The demonstrations took inspiration from protests that began in neighboring Spain last month over similar housing concerns. They come amid widespread social unrest across Europe this autumn.
Marching under the slogan “We won’t let them steal our right to housing,” participants ranged from teenagers to retirees. Drums, music and chants accompanied the Lisbon march as protesters carried large banners and flags.
Susana Pacheco, a 35-year-old data analyst who works part-time as an astrologer to help pay her mortgage, said she worried about whether her younger sister could afford to move out of their parents’ home.
“I’m really worried about young people,” Pacheco said. “I don’t know how they’re going to be able to pay” for their own home.
“Things have become intolerable,” said Ana Encarnação, 42, citing rising living costs and the widening gap between rich and poor.
Activists want ceilings placed on rent increases, greater legal protection for tenants against eviction, and more affordable housing.
House prices in Portugal have risen much faster than incomes, statistics show.
Between 2015 and 2025, Portugal posted the biggest jump in the European Union in the home price-to-income ratio, with an increase of 61%, followed by the Netherlands with 34%, the EU statistical office Eurostat said last week.
There is no indication that the rise in housing costs is slowing. Between the first quarter of last year and the first quarter of 2026, housing prices rose by almost 20%, the National Statistics Institute, a government agency, said last month.
Rental prices, too, have climbed significantly, recording a 68% increase since 2020, according to the government.
Foreign buyers and investment funds have fueled price rises by buying Portuguese real estate. The country’s mild climate and long coastline have helped it grow popular with digital nomads and other remote workers, as well as retirees. Tourism has also surged, with many city center apartments switched to short-term rentals.
The government has responded with measures such as lowering taxes on new construction, restricting short-term rentals and promising to build 145,000 new homes. But it acknowledges that the effects won’t be immediate.
Portuguese President António José Seguro, whose role is mostly ceremonial but who wields political influence, convened a Council of State, an advisory body, to discuss the protests earlier this month and met Friday with some of the protesters.
3 days ago
EU calls for unimpeded humanitarian aid access to Gaza
The European Union (EU) on Saturday urged Israel to reopen all Gaza border crossings to allow immediate, unimpeded access and sustained distribution of humanitarian assistance and early recovery support at scale.
In a statement published by the European External Action Service (EEAS), the EU reiterated its grave concern over the persistent and devastating humanitarian crisis in Gaza. It said the severe flooding and winter conditions impacting the enclave are further aggravating the living conditions of an already exhausted population, exacerbating unsafe conditions and human suffering.
The statement noted that a year after the ceasefire was announced, military strikes continue and shortages of essential items persist due to restricted access, resulting in the absence of acceptable and dignified living conditions.
The EU urged Israel to enable the work of the United Nations and its agencies, and humanitarian organizations, including non-governmental organizations, and to comply with all its obligations under international law, including international humanitarian law and international human rights law.
The bloc underlined the need to respect international law, including international humanitarian law, at all times, particularly the protection of civilians and civilian infrastructure, as well as medical personnel and facilities. It described the recent airstrike on Nasser Hospital as "deeply alarming."
Reaffirming its commitment to the two-state solution, the EU called on all actors to fully implement the provisions of UN Security Council Resolution 2803 without delay, in line with relevant UN Security Council resolutions and international political and legal principles, in particular the permanent decommissioning of weapons from Hamas and other non-state armed groups, the full withdrawal of Israeli forces from Gaza and the civilian transition in Gaza.
The statement stressed that Hamas should not have any role in the future governance of Gaza.
On Nov. 7, Gaza's civil defense authorities declared a state of maximum emergency as a rainstorm flooded around 70,000 tents housing displaced Palestinians and overwhelmed rescue services.
According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, about 1.4 million Palestinians, or 65 percent of Gaza's population, were living in tents or makeshift shelters. It warned that humanitarian shelter stocks inside Gaza were virtually exhausted, while more than 150,000 tents remained outside the territory awaiting entry. However, Israel says it restricts certain materials over concerns that Hamas could use them for military purposes.
3 days ago
How bomb threats are spooking Europe
A wave of hoax bomb threats targeting schools, airlines and media organizations has recently swept across Europe, disrupting public services and heightening security concerns.
As similar threats spill across national borders via hijacked email accounts and anonymous networks, European authorities face mounting pressure in identifying those responsible.
Though it remains unclear who is behind the threats hitting France, Spain, and other nations, European officials call them a coordinated effort to sow continent-wide confusion.
Regardless of who is responsible, how exactly are hoax bomb threats causing widespread disruption across Europe?
ORIGIN UNKNOWN
In Italy, around 6,300 schools received bomb threat emails on Wednesday, prompting widespread evacuations, while similar messages sent to schools in Scotland, Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland were dismissed as hoaxes.
The incidents followed a series of alerts involving European air travel in early November, when at least seven flights and a cruise ship were targeted in one incident, while nearly 30 passenger flights received hoax threats in another, prompting diversions, unplanned landings and fighter-jet escorts. Later, broadcasters in Ireland, Bulgaria and Britain were also targeted.
Across Europe, the threats caused widespread disruption, although no explosives were found and no injuries were reported.
The origins of the threats, however, remain unclear. An email sent to Italian schools was signed by a purported figure named "Mikhail Andropov," who also claimed responsibility for threats against newsrooms in Ireland and Bulgaria.
But the sender's identity remains unknown, and investigators have yet to establish whether the messages were linked to the threats against European flights. Authorities have not attributed the incidents to any group or state actor.
The threats could have been copycat incidents triggered by an initial alert, repeated actions by an individual or group, or hybrid warfare operations by state actors or their supporters, among several possible explanations outlined by Matthew Borie, co-founder and chief intelligence officer of Osprey Flight Solutions, which advises airlines on flight threats.
Spanish Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Albares described the incidents as a possible attempt at "hybrid aggression" and psychological warfare, arguing that the recurrence of similar incidents across Europe was unlikely to be mere coincidence.
He said cyberattacks on digital platforms and supermarket refrigeration systems also fit the pattern, in which hackers remotely manipulated temperature controls, causing refrigerators to warm up and food to spoil.
SECURITY CHALLENGES
In Italy, the government said a special technical group would begin work on Friday to develop procedures and tools for responding to such threats in the short, medium, and long term. These measures would apply not only to schools but also to other potential targets.
Addressing such threats requires not only national-level preparedness but also closer coordination among European countries and institutions.
"Europe needs a much more harmonised approach to security and a coordinating body to address these kinds of hybrid threats, rather than leaving individual countries and airlines to deal with them in isolation," said Jozsef Varadi, chief executive of Hungarian airline Wizz Air.
But he acknowledged that national sovereignty remained an obstacle to a unified response, as governments were reluctant to concede on security matters.
Despite these challenges, efforts to strengthen coordination at the EU level are already underway.
At the institutional level, the European Commission activated an aviation security information-sharing mechanism on Nov. 5 and convened security experts from EU member states, with Norway, Switzerland and Iceland also invited to discuss possible coordination measures.
TRIGGERING ANXIETY
One underlying vulnerability is how easily attackers can exploit digital communication channels to disrupt public institutions. "It's too easy. Any one of us can use the available means and instruments to send an email to a school, a daycare, an airline, saying that there's a bomb," Italian Defense Minister Guido Crosetto said Wednesday.
"This episode shows how much irresponsibility, when combined with the extraordinary communicative power of the tools we have today, can cause damage and disruption on a large scale," said Antonello Giannelli, head of the Italian School Principals Association.
Irish Prime Minister Micheal Martin also said threats against broadcasters illustrated how relatively simple unconventional activities could disrupt the normal functioning of society and generate fear and anxiety.
Social media can further amplify such anxiety by circulating unverified claims. In Scotland, false information about school bomb threats heightened parental concerns and contributed to falling attendance at some schools, according to an analysis by Glasgow City Council reported by The Times.
Although investigators found no evidence linking the online activity to the threatening emails, the case highlights how misinformation can compound the effects of hoax threats and deepen public unease.
"We are, of course, on high alert," French President Emmanuel Macron said on Thursday.
3 days ago
G7 focuses on Ukraine as US-led peace talks begin in Abu Dhabi
Top diplomats from the Group of Seven (G7) leading industrialised nations are focusing on support for Ukraine as trilateral talks involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States begin in the United Arab Emirates on Tuesday.
Ukrainian Foreign Minister Andrii Sybiha is scheduled to meet US Secretary of State Marco Rubio in Paris before joining a broader meeting with his G7 counterparts at the French foreign ministry.
The discussions will focus on defence and security assistance for Ukraine, which has been scaled back by US President Donald Trump's administration, raising concerns in Kyiv and European capitals, including Paris, Berlin, Rome and London.
It remained unclear whether Washington or any other G7 member would announce additional assistance for Ukraine.
At the same time, Trump's envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner are meeting Russian and Ukrainian officials in Abu Dhabi. One of the key objectives is to persuade Moscow to agree to broader negotiations involving major European representatives to find a way to end nearly five years of war.
European countries have been pressing to participate in the Abu Dhabi talks. However, two US officials said on Monday that representatives from Britain, Germany, France, NATO and the European Union would not take part in the main discussions. Instead, they would hold separate talks beforehand on possible security guarantees and the future security framework between Russia and Europe.
Moscow has opposed European participation in the negotiations, insisting that discussions should remain limited to Russia, Ukraine and the United States. The three countries last held talks in February.
German Foreign Minister Johan Wadephul, who met Rubio separately on the sidelines of the G7 meeting in Paris on Monday, stressed that Europe must have a place in the negotiations.
“I am still very grateful to the United States of America for making every effort to get the parties to the conflict to the table,” he said. “But I made clear again here that Europe belongs at this table. There can be no solution without Europe, only with Europe.”
Rubio said Washington did not oppose European involvement in direct negotiations at a later stage, but added that the time was not yet right.
“Ultimately, it would be a positive, but we've got a ways to go,” he told reporters after a day of group and bilateral meetings with G7 counterparts. “But, no, it's good that they're talking, it's good that the trilateral talks are on again. It's better than not having talks.”
Ahead of the Abu Dhabi meetings, Russia launched another assault on Ukraine's power grid on Monday, while Ukrainian forces struck another of Russia's largest oil refineries.
The two sides remain locked in fighting, with neither showing signs of backing away from their demands. Analysts and humanitarian organisations estimate that the war has killed hundreds of thousands of soldiers and thousands of civilians.
7 days ago
Gunman in Poland's Krakow shooting dies in hospital
The gunman who killed six people in the Polish city of Krakow on Saturday died in hospital early Monday, the Polish Press Agency (PAP) reported, citing local police.
Police said they were notified of his death by the hospital Monday morning, adding that prosecutors would release further details.
Prosecutors are investigating both the shooting and the killing of three members of the 24-year-old gunman's immediate family, whose bodies were found in a home in the Ostrowiec Swietokrzyski area in south-central Poland. Preliminary findings indicate that he was responsible for both incidents.
Autopsies on the victims were scheduled to begin Monday morning. Prosecutor Eryk Stasielak told PAP that the examinations could take two days because of the complex nature of the gunshot wounds.
The gunman drove into Krakow's Main Market Square on Saturday afternoon and fired at passersby randomly before being shot and detained by police. Officials said Saturday evening that six people had been killed and 16 others injured, including two police officers and the gunman.
8 days ago
French unions stage nationwide strikes, mounting pressure on Macron government
Tens of thousands of trade union members joined nationwide strikes and demonstrations across France on Thursday, demanding higher wages and backing a growing student protest movement, putting further pressure on President Emmanuel Macron’s government.
Major rallies were held in Paris, Lyon, Marseille and other cities after more than a month of recurring protests. Unions said around 260 demonstrations against rising living costs were planned across the country, with hundreds of thousands of people expected to take part.
Students also staged fresh protests, leaving about one-third of the country’s high schools closed or unable to operate due to student blockades and teacher strikes. Public transport services faced major disruptions, while the Eiffel Tower was also closed.
Despite heavy security, the atmosphere remained largely peaceful at Paris’s Place de la République, where the main march was scheduled to begin in the afternoon. The area had witnessed clashes between rioters and police during protests on October 17.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez said 70,000 police officers had been deployed, supported by armoured vehicles, drones and helicopters.
However, violence was reported in some areas. Authorities in Brittany said masked individuals attempted to block roads in Rennes, while young people, sometimes accompanied by adults, committed serious acts of violence, including throwing steel balls at police.
France’s major unions warned that the country was nearing recession and that job-cutting plans were increasing. They said the prices of fuel, food, rent, gas and electricity were rising while wages and pensions remained stagnant.
“The situation in this country is fragile. The pressing social and environmental challenges must be addressed without delay,” the unions said in a joint statement.
Fabien Villedieu, national secretary of the SUD-Rail union, criticised the government, railway operator SNCF and employers for failing to address workers’ concerns.
“When they’re not reasonable, we simply do what we’ve always done in France, which is to go on strike,” he told The Associated Press.
The government had held talks with unions ahead of the strikes in an effort to contain the unrest, which has become the country’s worst civil disturbance in years.
The protest movement began in September following demonstrations over staff shortages at a high school southeast of Paris. It later spread nationwide, drawing students demanding increased education funding and workers seeking better pensions and relief from rising fuel and living costs.
The protests are also unfolding as political parties prepare for next May’s presidential election. Macron is constitutionally barred from seeking a third consecutive term, while candidates are seeking to capitalise on public discontent.
Paul Smith, an associate professor of French history and politics at the University of Nottingham, said the next president would face major challenges amid widespread frustration over the government’s performance.
12 days ago