French President Emmanuel Macron’s upcoming move to formally recognize a Palestinian state has stirred sharp criticism from both Israel and the United States. The decision, intended to revive diplomatic momentum for a two-state solution amid the ongoing war in Gaza, has drawn fire for what opponents argue is a politically destabilizing gesture.
In a letter sent last week to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Macron emphasized that France’s support for Palestinian statehood stems from the belief that lasting peace is vital for Israel’s security. He described the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza as “unjustifiable” and underscored the urgency for a political resolution.
As the death toll in Gaza surpassed 63,000, according to the enclave’s Health Ministry, and Israel declared Gaza City a combat zone, Macron’s letter signaled a shift among Western powers. France, along with the UK, Canada, Australia, and Malta, plans to officially recognize a Palestinian state during the upcoming UN General Assembly session starting on September 23. New Zealand, Finland, and Portugal are reportedly weighing similar moves.
Netanyahu, who opposes Palestinian statehood and has vowed to intensify military operations in Gaza, condemned Macron’s stance. He accused the French leader of “fanning the flames of antisemitism” — a claim Macron rejected as “disgraceful.”
US Ambassador to France Charles Kushner echoed Israel’s position, warning in a letter that steps toward recognition could embolden extremists and jeopardize Jewish safety, including in France. His remarks prompted a formal response from the French Foreign Ministry.
“This strong reaction highlights how symbolic actions can carry significant weight,” said Pascal Boniface, a French geopolitical analyst. “There’s now a race between renewed diplomatic engagement focused on a two-state solution and an increasingly dire reality on the ground in Gaza that’s making such a solution harder to implement.”
Some advocates for Palestinian statehood expressed frustration that the recognition will be delayed until September, fearing that further destruction in Gaza will only complicate future diplomacy.
International leaders, including Macron, continue to urge Israel to halt its military offensive in the densely populated and war-torn Gaza Strip, where over 2 million people are displaced, infrastructure lies in ruins, and famine has taken hold.
In his letter, Macron warned that the occupation and forced displacement of Palestinians, along with policies leading to starvation, would not bring Israel peace. Instead, he argued, such actions would further isolate the country and fuel antisemitism globally.
While more than 140 countries already recognize Palestinian statehood—mostly as a symbolic gesture—analysts say Macron’s initiative could still have diplomatic impact.
Muhammad Shehada, a Gaza-based analyst and fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations, said the involvement of major Western powers counters Netanyahu’s narrative that mass displacement is the only path forward. “This move brings weight to the two-state vision and pressures Israel diplomatically,” he noted.
Backing Moderate Palestinian Leadership
France’s diplomatic push, led in coordination with Saudi Arabia, also secured a significant breakthrough earlier this year: a joint statement from all 22 Arab League nations condemning Hamas attacks on civilians. This marked the first such consensus, agreed upon at a July conference in New York.
In the declaration, Arab leaders called on Hamas to relinquish control of Gaza and disarm, handing over authority to the Palestinian Authority (PA)—a move intended to strengthen moderate Palestinian factions and lay groundwork for statehood talks.
Shehada said the plan may help weaken hardline elements within Hamas by signaling that diplomatic engagement, not violence, can lead to an independent Palestinian state. “This offers Palestinians a political path and an alternative to armed struggle,” he said.
The PA seeks statehood in the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem—territories seized by Israel during the 1967 war. However, the PA was expelled from Gaza in 2007 following a Hamas takeover and now governs limited areas of the Israeli-occupied West Bank.
Despite renewed European support, the Palestinian Authority remains unpopular among many Palestinians, who view it as corrupt and ineffective. Nonetheless, Macron and other leaders continue to view a reformed PA as central to achieving a lasting peace.