The Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) on Sunday rejected the BGMEA's objections to its garment minimum wage analysis, saying that using the exchange's proposed household-size figure would reduce its poverty-line-based wage estimate by only Tk 186, from Tk 18,578 to Tk 18,392.
In a letter to BGMEA President Mahmud Hasan Khan, CPD Executive Director Nazneen Ahmed responded point by point to the trade body's November 19 observations on CPD's media briefing of November 18.
BGMEA had questioned the household size and number of earners per family used by CPD.
In reply, CPD said it used four members per household and 1.58 earners, both medians of values from several published studies.
It said the simple average of household size across five sources is 3.93, a negligible difference from 4.
CPD also noted that the 2022 Household Income and Expenditure Survey (HIES) of the Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS) puts urban household size at 4.18 and the national figure at 4.26.
"CPD's figure is lower than the urban average, so household size was not inflated deliberately to raise the wage estimate," the letter said.
On BGMEA's suggestion to use 3.96 members from the BBS Socioeconomic and Demographic Survey (SEDS) 2023, CPD said the result changes little, and that its analysis is based mainly on HIES 2022, which has detailed data on household spending and poverty.
On earners, CPD said the HIES 2022 urban figure is 1.37 per household. Using that instead would make the required wage per earner higher, not lower, it said.
CPD acknowledged that its figures are indicative, not based on a new representative survey.
It said it had not claimed that worker families have grown larger or that the number of earners has fallen since its 2023 study, which covered 228 workers from 76 factories.
Rejecting BGMEA's proposal to average urban and rural poverty lines, CPD said that would wrongly give both equal weight without data on where workers live.
It said a weighted average based on worker numbers by area could be calculated if BGMEA provides the data, but weighting by export volume would not be appropriate.
CPD also said the Dhaka Urban poverty line covers urban areas of the whole Dhaka division, including industrial areas such as Gazipur and Narayanganj, not only Dhaka city.
On BGMEA's concern about double counting housing costs, CPD said it removed house rent from non-food spending and tobacco from food spending before calculating other essentials.
It said slide 22 of its presentation listed those essentials as clothing, utilities, education, transport, personal care and communication.
CPD said the 9 percent annual increment, in effect since December 1, 2024, raised pay for existing workers but is separate from the minimum wage for new entrants.
The entry-grade minimum wage remains Tk 12,500, it said.
CPD said it focused on entry-grade wages because they are the basis of wage board talks.
It said it offered a range rather than a fixed figure because updated data on factory costs, prices and profits is lacking, with the lower end reflecting basic needs and the upper end reflecting the industry's capacity to pay.
CPD summed up its position in three points. It called for wages to be set on the basis of large scientific surveys of both workers and factories, following the criteria in Section 141 of the Bangladesh Labour Act 2006.
It said it supports higher wages but does not support vandalism or violence. It also urged the wage board to weigh workers' needs and the economy's realities, saying the cost of energy shortages, high interest rates and governance failures should not be passed on to workers through low pay.
CPD said it remains keen to continue data-based dialogue with BGMEA, labour organisations and other stakeholders.