United Nations climate negotiations ended without an overarching agreement on Sunday as countries remained sharply divided over whether to explicitly mention fossil fuels, the main drivers of global warming.
Expectations were already low ahead of the two-week COP31 talks in Turkey, but disagreements over fossil fuels, climate finance and other issues proved impossible to resolve.
Although the negotiations made progress on several smaller issues, countries failed to reach consensus on the main agreement, known as the cover decision.
The deadlock came as global warming continues to intensify, triggering increasingly severe heat waves, floods, storms and droughts. The United Nations has warned that the world is certain to exceed the 1.5-degree Celsius warming limit set under the 2015 Paris Agreement in the near future.
The situation has been further complicated by a global energy shock linked to the war in Iran, while a strong El Niño is adding to human-induced warming and extreme weather events.
Climate agreements require near-unanimous consensus. Several countries and the European Union's 27 member states rejected the final proposal presented by the Turkish-Australian COP31 leadership because it made no explicit reference to fossil fuels.
A considerably larger number of countries were willing to accept the proposal, albeit reluctantly, arguing that reaching a consensus was more important. However, the effort ultimately failed, with Russia and Saudi Arabia among those seeking to keep fossil fuels out of the document.
"It's unconscionable that we would have a climate act that makes no reference to fossil fuels," Ireland's Climate Minister Darragh O'Brien said on behalf of the EU as the negotiations in the Turkish resort city of Antalya continued nearly 48 hours beyond schedule.
Disagreements over draft agreements
Fossil fuels had remained absent from COP final decisions for more than 25 years before a landmark agreement three years ago called for "transitioning away from fossil fuels" at COP28 in the United Arab Emirates, said Alden Meyer of the think tank E3G.
Since then, however, there has been no explicit reference to fossil fuels in subsequent agreements. The Turkish-Australian proposal reproduced the Dubai language in full, but many countries and environmental groups considered it insufficient.
Another major point of contention was the draft's inclusion of specific language and a target for carbon capture and storage by industrial polluters. Several countries and climate activists argued that such provisions could undermine efforts to reduce overall emissions.
Rachel Cleetus of the Union of Concerned Scientists blamed wealthy countries, oil-producing states and the Turkish-Australian COP leadership for failing to deliver ambitious, equitable and science-based outcomes.
As the proposed agreement collapsed during the plenary session, Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum, who chaired COP31, was absent. Elchin Allahverdiyev of Azerbaijan announced that the negotiations had failed to produce an overarching agreement.
"Unfortunately, we were unable to reach agreement on a cover decision. And that's disappointing, very disappointing," said Australia's Chris Bowen, COP31's president of negotiations.
Bowen said the commitment made in Dubai to move away from coal, oil and natural gas remained valid.
"Transition away from fossil fuels in the real world is happening. It's happening. It's happening at speed and it's irreversible," he said.
Other climate issues remain unresolved
Several other issues also remained unsettled, with many discussions deferred to next year's climate negotiations in Ethiopia. These include details of the transition away from fossil fuels, financial assistance for vulnerable countries to adapt to climate change, and measures addressing gender and climate issues.
Turkey had made global electrification a key priority of this year's negotiations. A separate proposal called on countries to increase electricity's share of total final energy consumption from around 21 percent currently to 35 percent by 2035.
Achieving the target would require shifting transportation, including cars, trucks and planes, away from fossil fuels and replacing coal with electricity in industrial production. Nearly 100 countries signed up to the separate pledge.
In negotiations on the main agreement, the final proposal was circulated after 3am, leaving negotiators little time to raise objections.
Many observers and participating countries blamed the joint Turkish-Australian leadership for the failure to reach an overall agreement.
Antwi-Boasiako Amoah, chair of the African Group of Negotiators, criticised the proceedings, saying the COP president had failed to show respect to the group's 54 African countries and Ghana.
Confusion also emerged during the meeting after Turkish Environment Minister Kurum was caught on a hot microphone telling UN climate chief Simon Stiell to "sit down" as Stiell attempted to advise him on the proceedings.
Earlier in the week, Panamanian Environment Minister Juan Carlos Navarro accused a "petroleum mafia" of holding the negotiations hostage and called for reforms.
Manuel Pulgar-Vidal, president of COP20 and now climate and energy lead at the World Wildlife Fund, said COP31 had left too many issues unresolved.
"Too many once again shied away from the toughest decisions, including how to turn their commitment to transition away from fossil fuels into real action," he said, adding that the climate would not wait for governments to find the courage to act.
Earlier this year, the United Nations Environment Programme warned that the world would exceed the Paris Agreement's goal of limiting long-term warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius (2.7 degrees Fahrenheit) above pre-industrial levels.
UN officials have said the priority should now be to limit the extent of the overshoot and eventually bring temperatures down through technologies that remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.
Scientists estimate that the world is on track for warming of between 2.7 and 3 degrees Celsius (4.9 to 5.4 degrees Fahrenheit) by the end of the century.
October 2026 recorded the highest temperature increase above pre-industrial levels of any month on record, reaching 1.8 degrees Celsius (3.2 degrees Fahrenheit), according to Berkeley Earth, which estimated a 97 percent chance that 2026 would become the warmest year on record.