Describing the judgement of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) against Myanmar as a historic ruling, the International Crisis Group (ICG) on Thursday said the world court found a state responsible for committing genocide for the first time.
"This is a historic ruling. For the first time, the world court has found a state responsible for committing genocide – and the man who commanded those operations is now Myanmar's president," ICG Senior Adviser for Asia Richard Horsey said in an instant reaction to the judgement delivered by the UN court.
He said Rohingyas waited for nine years to hear a court say this. “It will not change their lives quickly, but it puts what was done to them on the legal record, and no amount of denial in Naypyitaw can remove it," he added.
"Governments rolling out the red carpet for Min Aung Hlaing will now be doing so for the head of a state found responsible for genocide. Most will carry on regardless, but it will be harder to present this as business as usual," Richard Horsey said.
He said the court has no means of enforcing this ruling. "What matters now is whether the governments engaging Naypyitaw are prepared to attach any cost to ignoring it."
"I do not expect this to stop Min Aung Hlaing's travels. Governments that have welcomed him despite an ICC arrest warrant hanging over his head are unlikely to change course over this ruling," the ICG senior adviser said.
He said it is likely to make Naypyitaw more defensive in its dealings with the UN, at the very moment it is trying to win back Myanmar's seat in New York.
"Most of the land the Rohingyas fled is now held by the Arakan Army, an ethnic Rakhine armed group fighting Naypyitaw. For Rohingyas still in Myanmar’s Rakhine State, how the Arakan Army treats them will matter more than anything Naypyitaw says," Richard Horsey said.
He said nearly 1.2 million Rohingyas are in camps in Bangladesh, where food rations have been reduced due to aid funding cuts. “Hopefully this ruling will be a reminder of their plight to donors, who need to step up," he said.
"How the court has handled the question of intent will now be read very closely in the cases against Israel and Russia," the ICG senior adviser said.