The Head of Multimedia at United News of Bangladesh (UNB) was assaulted by a group of 15 to 20 men carrying bamboo sticks, while covering the aftermath of Monday night’s cocktail blasts in the capital’s Shahjadpur.
Shovy Zibran, who carries an Irish passport but has roots in Bangladesh, said he was attacked near the Suvastu Nazar Valley shopping centre and apartment complex after being falsely accused of having links with the Awami League, despite repeatedly identifying himself as a journalist.
According to his account, the incident began at approximately 8:27pm when what sounded like crude bombs exploded outside a residential building and a CNG station in the area.
Hearing the explosion, Shovy immediately went to the scene carrying his mobile phone and press identification to gather footage for a news report.
Upon reaching the scene, he spoke with police officers and examined the blast site. However, he found little recoverable evidence, as the remaining debris had already been burnt.
He subsequently approached witnesses to establish the circumstances surrounding the explosion.
These witnesses told him that unidentified individuals had thrown crude bombs, commonly known as cocktail bombs, on the opposite side of the main road near Popular Hospital, before fleeing the area.
These accounts are consistent with the accounts of three cocktail blasts in quick succession in the Shahjadpur area near Popular Hospital, that was reported by multiple news outlets last night (see Ittefaq, Amar Desh, Dhaka Tribune).
While interviewing witnesses, Shovy heard a commotion outside the Lazz Pharma outlet in the area, which happens to be on the same side of the road as his residence, i.e. opposite to Popular Hospital, where the blasts occurred.
It may be mentioned the two sides here are either side of the Bishwa Road, one of the longest and widest communication arteries in the capital.
Shovy made his way to the location of the commotion and found some civilians detaining three men, as they waited for police to arrive. It soon became clear the ones doing the detaining were linked to the ruling party in some way or another.
They accused the three detainees of belonging to the Awami League or its offshoots, and also alleged they had been responsible for the ‘crude bomb’ attack in the area that had comprised three cocktail explosions in quick succession, hardly 10-15 minutes earlier.
Shovy of course had not witnessed the explosions or who caused them. Nor it seemed, had anyone else. The most incriminating evidence against the trio being detained seemed to be that they were caught in the act of ‘running away’.
He remained at the scene to document the police response.
Attacked for filming police?
The police found it convincing enough though, and began putting handcuffs on the detained men. Shovy started recording the incident on his mobile phone around then, with the three accused in the back of a police van.
During the recording, which goes haywire rather abruptly amid a rising commotion, several individuals began pushing him, Shovy alleges. He insists he explained immediately to anyone who would listen that he was a journalist, gathering footage for a news report. Besides, his press identification was on display around his neck at all times.
"I was the only journalist present at the scene. I was wearing my ID on my neck," Shovy said.
The fact that he was the only journalist there, thanks to being a resident of the area, may have been the reason the crowd started viewing him, and his activities which included recording video on his phone, with suspicion.
Shortly after police left the area with the detained trio, one of the men who had been pushing him earlier now began accusing Shovy of being associated with Awami League. That same individual kept trying to encourage others at the scene to attack him, Shovy said.
Shovy kept insisting, even shouting to be heard above the din, that he was a journalist with UNB. But it was to no avail, as he said 15-20 men soon surrounded and attacked him. .
Several of the attackers were carrying bamboo sticks, which they used to strike Shovy on his head, right shoulder and right thigh, he said. The force of the blows left their marks, as the photos show.
"I have two clips where you can hear me shout that I'm a journalist," Shovy said. UNB is in possession of the recordings, that closely mirror his testimony. They capture his despairing attempts to identify himself as a journalist, believing that identity could somehow shield him from the crowd’s worst tendencies. It did not.
Shovy alleged that the individuals involved in the assault were affiliated with the ruling BNP. This is straightforward enough, given that they came from among those who were part of the vigilante groups springing up with vows to protect the country from Awami League and Chhatra League, and to work “in aid of police”.
The overwhelming majority of these groups are populated by members of the BNP and its affiliate organisations.
Shovy also said he subsequently received "information" suggesting connections between some of the attackers and Nazrul Islam Mona, who has held senior leadership positions in the Jatiotabadi Swechhasebak Dal’s Gulshan unit.
Short of a police investigation into the incident though, the said connections remain tenuous at best.
Are foreign journalists safe in Bangladesh?
Shovy, an Irish citizen working in Bangladesh, said the attack raised serious questions about the safety of journalists in general, and foreign journalists were bound to take note. He was particularly disturbed by how a political label could be used so readily to justify violence.
"I'm an Irish citizen working in Bangladesh. They attacked a foreign journalist with false claims," Shovy said.
He maintained that he was not participating in any political activity and had been present solely to document the aftermath of the explosion in his locality and the subsequent police action.
The incident raises concerns about the safety of journalists covering politically sensitive developments in Bangladesh, particularly when allegations of political affiliation can be made without evidence.
It also raises questions about the protections available to journalists at volatile crime scenes in these politically charged times. Running short of ideas as a mob closed in on him, Shovy had even called 999 for help at one point.
The incident raises a fundamental question press-freedom concern: whether journalists can safely document events of public interest without becoming targets of politically motivated accusations.